
Gizmodo recently posted an article bashing AT&T’s MicroCell service. And even though Verizon, Sprint, and T-Mobile charge for similar services, they choose to single out AT&T in this case. Now, I hate to be Devil’s advocate, but seriously, at least make sure AT&T’s largest competitor isn’t sponsoring your website first!
So, Gizmodo, sponsored by Sprint, writes that “AT&T’s network is basically a huge failure.” Well, let’s take a look at some coverage maps to see if that claim is really justified:

It comes close, but AT&T’s tower density is definately higher. Sprint has nowhere near the same number and spread of towers as AT&T has. Plus, several testimonials about switching from AT&T to Sprint have been very positive.
I frankly wasn’t expecting much in the way of 3G coverage where I live – in the backwoods of Charleston, WV. I figured I’d be able to utilize 3G only in my business travels – after all, Sprint has never provided EV-DO in this area. I was wrong! AT&T has superb 3G coverage throughout the Charleston metropolitan area. I even get 5 bars of 3G service in my home! During my recent drive to family in VA I ran into Edge-only areas of coverage, but nevertheless I was able to make cell phone calls while driving and without any dropped or poor quality calls. Once arriving in the Manassas and Fredericksburg areas where my family lives, I again encountered very strong 3G signal strength. As I’ve already mentioned a couple of times I didn’t even bother utilizing free WiFi at my hotel in Woodbridge, VA because the 3G service was so fast there. –http://mconnick.wordpress.com/2008/08/06/att-vs-sprint/
I’m not for AT&T, personally I have T-Mobile, but I have to say that Gizmodo was being quite unfair to AT&T and their MicroCell service. After all, Sprint does charge $20 for their service as well; AT&T’s just matching the competition. It’s better to have a MicroCell than nothing, right?
I admit that AT&T does not have the best coverage in the world, but when I was driving from my home city of Toronto - I have both Canadian and US cellular phones - to Washington DC, I noticed that my iPhone would keep on consistently picking up AT&T signal where T-Mobile failed to do so. And when T-Mobile handed off service to AT&T, I always got full signal strength.
So, why is everybody hating on AT&T, well, it’s beyond me. Their plans all include Caller ID, a feature that Rogers in Canada feels compelled to charge almost $10 extra for, and their $30 Unlimited Data is nothing compared to the 500MB we get here for the same price.
To all of you who have AT&T, stop whining, and if you think you like another carrier better, switch. That’s all I have to say.
This post was written by j.dhanani, and he/she may not represent the opinions of this website or it's owner.
Recent Comments